Your shopping cart is currently empty. Please choose from one of our categories to start shopping!
Filter by
Price
- $100.00 or less (0)
- $100.01 - $250.00 (6)
- $250.01 - $500.00 (5)
- $500.01 - $2,500.00 (8)
- $2,500.01 or more (2)
Bargain Bin
- No (21)
Certified
- Yes (21)
Denomination
- Indian Cent (21)
Mint
- S (1)
U.S. Indian Head Cents (1859-1909)
U.S. Indian Head Cents (1859-1909)
1867 Indian Cent NGC XF45 BN Decent Eye Appeal Nice Strike
SKU: PSB55356
SKU: PSB55356
This original 1867 Indian Cent has decent eye appeal and nice strike. Nice chocolate brown color. Couple freckles. Certified: NGC XF45 BN
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $167.00 | $172.00 |
1868 Indian Cent NGC MS63 RB Nice Eye Appeal Nice Strike
SKU: PSB49383
SKU: PSB49383
This original 1868 Indian Cent has nice eye appeal with nice luster and nice strike. Lots more Red than Brown. Likely a 64 or 65 if not for the spot on obverse. Certified: NGC MS63 RB
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $443.00 | $455.00 |
1868 Indian Cent NGC MS65 BN Nice Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB56730
SKU: PSB56730
This 1868 Indian Cent has nice eye appeal with nice luster and strong strike. Interesting color. Razor sharp. Certified: NGC MS65 BN
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $830.00 | $855.00 |
1869 Indian Cent NGC AU53 BN Superb Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB54578
SKU: PSB54578
This wonderfully original 1869 Indian Cent has superb eye appeal and strong strike. Absolutely perfect chocolate brown color and surfaces. Certified: NGC AU53 BN
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $495.00 | $509.00 |
1869 Indian Cent NGC MS66 RB Superb Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB46771
SKU: PSB46771
This original 1869 Indian Cent has superb eye appeal with fantastic luster and strong strike. Gorgeous electric blue highlights. Beautiful! Certified: NGC MS66 RB
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $3,400.00 | $3,500.00 |
1869 Indian Cent NGC VF35 BN Superb Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB44592
SKU: PSB44592
This wonderfully original 1869 Indian Cent has superb eye appeal and strong strike. Outstanding color and surfaces. Certified: NGC VF35 BN
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $344.00 | $354.00 |
1870 Indian Cent NGC MS64 RD Nice Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB55357
SKU: PSB55357
This 1870 Indian Cent has nice eye appeal with nice luster and strong strike. Interesting color and surfaces. Tough to find this nice! Certified: NGC MS64 RD
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $1,650.00 | $1,700.00 |
1870/18-0 Indian Cent DDO FS-101 NGC XF40 BN Superb Eye Appeal
SKU: PSB48914
SKU: PSB48914
This wonderfully original 1870/18-0 Indian Cent DDO has superb eye appeal and nice strike. Gorgeous chocolate brown color and surfaces. Certified: NGC XF40 BN
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $437.00 | $450.00 |
1871 Indian Cent Proof NGC PF66 RB Nice Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB56199
SKU: PSB56199
This original 1871 Indian Cent has nice eye appeal with nice luster and strong strike. Nice color and surfaces. Tough to find! Certified: NGC PF66 RB
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $2,475.00 | $2,545.00 |
1872 Indian Cent NGC Unc Details Superb Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB55958
SKU: PSB55958
This 1872 Indian Cent has superb eye appeal with nice luster and strong strike. Looks 64/65 reddish. Great value! Certified: NGC Unc Details
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $1,035.00 | $1,065.00 |
1875 Indian Cent NGC Unc Details Great Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB55959
SKU: PSB55959
This 1875 Indian Cent has great eye appeal with fantastic luster and strong strike. Looks 63/64 Red. Certified: NGC Unc Details
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $313.00 | $322.00 |
1876 Indian Cent NGC VF35 BN Superb Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB55316
SKU: PSB55316
This wonderfully original 1876 Indian Cent has superb eye appeal and strong strike. Nearly perfect chocolate brown color and surfaces. Certified: NGC VF35 BN
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $151.00 | $156.00 |
1877 Indian Cent NGC VF35 BN Key Date Superb Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB53566
SKU: PSB53566
This wonderfully original 1877 Indian Cent has superb eye appeal and strong strike. Gorgeous chocolate brown color and surfaces. Certified: NGC VF35 BN
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $1,805.00 | $1,860.00 |
1887 Indian Cent NGC MS64 RB Great Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB53824
SKU: PSB53824
This wonderfully original 1887 Indian Cent has great eye appeal with nice luster and strong strike. Outstanding color and surfaces. Certified: NGC MS64 RB
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $261.00 | $268.00 |
1889 Indian Cent Proof NGC PF66 RB Superb Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB56201
SKU: PSB56201
This wonderfully original 1889 Indian Cent has superb eye appeal with fantastic luster and strong strike. Pretty colors. Absolutely outstanding color and surfaces. Certified: NGC PF66 RB
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $1,135.00 | $1,170.00 |
1890 Indian Cent NGC MS63 RB Nice Eye Appeal Nice Strike
SKU: PSB53829
SKU: PSB53829
This original 1890 Indian Cent has nice eye appeal and nice strike. Relatively even red/brown ratio. Certified: NGC MS63 RB
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $157.00 | $161.00 |
1891 Indian Cent NGC MS63 RB Great Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB56871
SKU: PSB56871
This original 1891 Indian Cent has great eye appeal with fantastic luster and strong strike. Waaay more Red than Brown. Great color and surfaces. Certified: NGC MS63 RB
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $157.00 | $161.00 |
1894 Indian Cent NGC MS65 RB Nice Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB55359
SKU: PSB55359
This original 1894 Indian Cent has nice eye appeal with nice luster and strong strike. Nice color and surfaces. Certified: NGC MS65 RB
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $675.00 | $695.00 |
1899 Indian Cent NGC MS64 RB Superb Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB52595
SKU: PSB52595
This wonderfully original 1899 Indian Cent has superb eye appeal with fantastic luster and strong strike. Outstanding color and surfaces. More Red than Brown. Easily could have graded 65RB. Certified: NGC MS64 RB
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $177.00 | $182.00 |
1901 Indian Cent NGC MS64 RB Nice Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB56030
SKU: PSB56030
This wonderfully original 1901 Indian Cent has nice eye appeal with nice luster and strong strike. Nice even red/brown color and surfaces. Certified: NGC MS64 RB
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $141.00 | $145.00 |
Learn More About U.S. Indian Head Cents (1859-1909)
The Indian Head penny has long been a popular coin among coin collectors due to the historical significance of its era. The 1864-L, 1877, 1908-S, and 1909-S represent some of the most sought-after years by collectors. The Indian Head was the replacement penny for the Flying Eagle, which was only struck from 1856-1858 due to design flaws. Like the Flying Eagle, the Indian Head was designed by James Longacre, a chief engraver of the U.S. Mint. The Indian Head penny features an Indian head that faces to the left wearing a feather bonnet. The coin’s reverse side shows “ONE CENT” with a laurel wreath. The wreath was changed slightly in 1860 to include three arrows and a shield of the United States. According to the U.S. Department of the Treasury, over 1.8 billion Indian Cent pieces were minted. The composition of these coins evolved from 88% copper 12% nickel (1859-1864) to 95% copper 5% tin and zinc (1864-1909).
How much is an Indian Head penny worth? Contact our expert numismatists at 1-800-965-2646.